The Disappearance of Peggy McGuire
Episode 247
Mary Jimmie “Bobo” Shinn
Twenty-eight year old Peggy Anne McGuire was last seen dropping her son off for school in Canadian, Oklahoma on the morning of Monday, November 16th, 2015. Within hours of leaving the school, the single mother would mysterious disappear leaving behind a series of confusing clues which continue to cloud the truth.
The day after her disappearance a local bar captured an unidentified individual on surveillance footage abandoning Peggy's truck in the early morning hours before disappearing into the pre-dawn darkness. That individual has never been identified nor has anyone been named a person of interest or suspect.
For Peggy's family, there's only one suspect -- her ex-boyfriend and the father of her son, Thomas McIntosh. They claim McIntosh was a violent and abusive man who threatened Peggy's life on multiple occasions in the years leading up to her disappearance. McGuire's cell phone data shows she arrived home that morning and disappeared from somewhere surrounding the house she shared with her ex, Mr. McIntosh.
LISTEN NOW
Sources:
Apr 16, 2015, page 7 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
Apr 16, 2015, page 9 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Nov 26, 2015, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Nov 29, 2015, page 20 - Tulsa World at Newspapers.com
Dec 03, 2015, page 3 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
Dec 03, 2015, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Dec 03, 2015, page 3 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Dec 09, 2015, page 14 - Tulsa World at Newspapers.com
Dec 10, 2015, page 5 - The Daily Oklahoman at Newspapers.com
Dec 10, 2015, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Dec 17, 2015, page 8 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
Dec 17, 2015, page 2 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Dec 17, 2015, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Dec 24, 2015, page 7 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
Dec 24, 2015, page 5 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Dec 31, 2015, page 3 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Jan 14, 2016, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Jan 14, 2016, page 3 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
Jan 22, 2016, page 7 - Tulsa World at Newspapers.com
Jan 28, 2016, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Jan 28, 2016, page 7 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Feb 04, 2016, page 16 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Feb 11, 2016, page 8 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Mar 10, 2016, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Mar 10, 2016, page 2 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Mar 10, 2016, page 3 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
Apr 07, 2016, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Apr 07, 2016, page 3 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Apr 07, 2016, page 6 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
Nov 03, 2016, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Nov 03, 2016, page 2 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Nov 17, 2016, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Nov 17, 2016, page 2 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Nov 17, 2016, page 2 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Dec 29, 2016, page 3 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Jun 01, 2017, page 5 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
Jun 01, 2017, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Jun 01, 2017, page 3 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
May 10, 2018, page 7 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
May 10, 2018, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
May 10, 2018, page 2 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
May 31, 2018, page 1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
May 31, 2018, page 3 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Nov 25, 2021, page a1 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Nov 25, 2021, page a2 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Dec 30, 2021, page a9 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Mar 28, 2024, page a6 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
Peggy Anne McGuire – The Charley Project
Dec 17, 1992, page 10 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Jul 14, 1994, page 9 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
May 11, 1995, page 8 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
May 18, 1995, page 10 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Jun 11, 1998, page 6 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Jul 02, 1998, page 6 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Sep 17, 1998, page 3 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Dec 05, 2004, page 77 - Sequoyah County Times at Newspapers.com
Apr 13, 2006, page 7 - McIntosh County Democrat at Newspapers.com
Oct 14, 2010, page 6 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Mar 21, 2013, page 13 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com
Lawrence Journal World, Nov 30, 2015, p. 13
McAlester News-Capital & Democrat
McAlester News-Capital & Democrat 11/19/2015
Muskogee Daily Phoenix and Times-Democrat - 11/19/2015
McAlester News-Capital & Democrat - 11/25/2015
Muskogee Daily Phoenix and Times-Democrat - 11/28/2015
McAlester News-Capital & Democrat - 12/08/2015
Muskogee Daily Phoenix and Times-Democrat - 12/09/2015
Muskogee Daily Phoenix and Times-Democrat - 01/03/2016
Muskogee Daily Phoenix and Times-Democrat - 01/12/16
McAlester News-Capital & Democrat - 11/16/2016
Muskogee Daily Phoenix and Times-Democrat - 11/16/2016
Muskogee Daily Phoenix and Times-Democrat - 04/11/2017
McAlester News-Capital & Democrat - 02/23/2021
Search underway for missing Eufaula woman | www.fox23.com
Family pleads for missing woman's return
Officials looking into evidence as family continues search for missing woman
Family of missing Eufaula woman continue to search for clues - KJRH.com
Few Clues to Whereabouts of Peggy McGuire Who Vanished After Dropping Son off at School
Family continues search for missing Eufaula woman
Search continues for missing 28-year-old woman
OSBI agents searching for missing McIntosh County woman
Nearly 1 month later: Agents continue to search for missing Oklahoma mother | KFOR.com Oklahoma City
Authorities Searching McIntosh County For Missing Eufaula Woman
Search cont. for missing McIntosh County woman
OSBI agents scour McIntosh County for missing woman
Neighbors Say McIntosh County Woman 'Vanished Into Thin Air'
Search Officially on for Missing Stidham Woman - www.1170kfaq.com
(29) Search For Peggy Mcguire - YouTube
Battle emerges over missing Eufaula woman's son | News | fox23.com
Search underway for missing Eufaula woman | FOX23
"MCGUIRE, PEGGY A. VS. MCINTOSH, THOMAS R. " (PO-2006-00032) | On Demand Court Records
Warrant results produce leads in search for missing McIntosh County woman | FOX23
OSBI finds new evidence in missing woman's case
OSBI investigation reveals evidence found at missing McIntosh County woman's home - KJRH.com
One year later: Search continues for Peggy McGuire | FOX23
Family Looking For Missing Eufaula Mom Creates Message In The Snow
Eufaula mother still missing two years later
Family searches for answers years after Peggy McGuire's disappearance | News | fox23.com
Five years of Dateline's Missing in America: 109 still missing
Warrant results produce leads in search for missing McIntosh County woman | FOX23
Peggy McGuire: What's In A Name?
Family & Friends Remember Eufaula Woman 7 Years After Her Disappearance
Family Of Missing Eufaula Woman Searching For Answers Almost 9 Years After Her Disappearance
(2) 115 | The DIsappearance of Peggy McGuire: What's In A Name - YouTube
411630 E 1130 Rd - Google Maps
Betty's petition for grandparent rights.pdf - Google Drive
Betty's response to Thomas's motion to dismiss.pdf - Google Drive
Order appointing guardian.pdf - Google Drive
Thomas sues Betty for stolen cows.pdf - Google Drive
Betty's response to cow lawsuit.pdf - Google Drive
May 16, 1991, page 12 - The Indian Journal at Newspapers.com